Gamers Confess Their Sins: From Hating RDR2 to Loving WWE 2K20
Reddit's gaming confessions expose players' massive backlogs and honest unpopular opinions on beloved classics like Red Dead Redemption 2.
In the sprawling landscape of gaming forums in 2026, hot takes fly faster than a speedrunner in a glitchfest. Everyone has an opinion about frame rates, microtransactions, and whether Elden Ring II actually needed that battle royale mode. But hidden beneath the noise, a quiet phenomenon endures: the gaming confession. A safe space on Reddit’s r/gaming recently threw open its digital doors, inviting players to unburden their souls. What followed was a torrent of truths so candid, so raw, they might make a Chozo statue weep.
The original poster (OP), known as AndyKaufmanSentMe, kicked things off with a confession that might leave Gen Alpha scratching their heads: they hadn't touched a new Zelda game since Twilight Princess on the GameCube. In an era where Breath of the Wild and its sequel are practically national holidays, this was akin to admitting you still use a flip phone. But the thread quickly spiraled into far juicier territory.
One of the most relatable confessions came from a user who admitted, "I have a lot of games with zero to less than an hour of play. And I'm still buying new games." Ah, the eternal backlog. They elaborated that frequency had lessened, thanks only to the lure of Steam sales and the occasional Epic giveaway. Many modern gamers would nod in pained solidarity, staring at their library counts—numbers that resemble the GDP of small nations. It’s the Collector’s Curse: the dopamine hit of a purchase outpaces the will to actually play. The community responded with a collective sigh of recognition, spawning sub-threads about how to cope with the mounting guilt of unpurchased gems gathering digital dust.
But the real fireworks flew when someone dared to criticize a sacred cow—Red Dead Redemption 2. "I found RDR tedious," they wrote, their words hovering like a live grenade. Yet surprisingly, sympathy rolled in. Others chimed in that Rockstar’s opus was masterclass in atmospheric storytelling but also in glacially slow pacing, where looting a single drawer could take an eternity. One commenter took it a step further, slamming the entire concept of "masterpieces" on Reddit: "I’ve been duped multiple times by various games' wild popularity, only to be disappointed by grind and repetition." They listed titles that shall remain unnamed to avoid a flame war. It turned out that many players had been silently stewing, afraid to voice dislike for The Witcher 3, Persona 5, or even Breath of the Wild. In this thread, they found liberation. It was a quiet uprising against peer-pressure gaming, where it's finally okay to say, "I don't get the hype." The quiet nodding in the comments proved that the emperor of gaming might occasionally be wearing no clothes.
But not all confessions were born of frustration. A genuinely moving story came from a Redditor who revealed how The Witcher 3 entered their life at their lowest point. Jobless, reeling from a breakup, and mentally adrift, they stumbled into the world of Geralt of Rivia. They binge-read the books at Barnes & Noble, powered through the first two games, and lost themselves in the third.
"I still don't fully understand it but my mind felt so much clearer when I finished the game and the issues that I was dealing with didn't really hold that much weight to me," they wrote. Science has been dabbling in the mental health benefits of gaming, and while more research is needed, stories like this serve as living proof that a well-told game can be a lifeline. Take that, naysayers who think games rot brains. This confession turned the thread into something more than humorous venting; it became a testament to the quiet power of interactive storytelling.
Then there was the confession that broke all scales of rational thought. One Redditor proudly announced: "I platinumed WWE 2K20. And I liked it." The sheer audacity. For those blissfully unaware, WWE 2K20 is often remembered as a glitch-riddled catastrophe where wrestlers’ faces would swap with referees or limbs would contort into Lovecraftian nightmares. Earning a platinum trophy in that game is less an achievement and more an act of profound masochism. The original poster’s bold italicized enjoyment was met with a mix of horror and grudging respect. Some things are simply beyond comprehension—like enjoying a game that appears to be actively trying to unmake itself. Could it be that they were actually a developer in disguise, or just a connoisseur of chaos? The world may never know. It was a reminder that even in a hobby fueled by consensus, there will always be outliers who find diamonds in the roughest of glitch-mines.
These confessions reveal a simple truth: behind every gamer’s profile is a messy human. They buy games they’ll never play, secretly hate award-winning epics, find solace in dark times through digital worlds, and sometimes develop Stockholm syndrome for broken wrestling sims. In 2026, as the gaming industry barrels forward with ever more content, the confession booth remains as vital as ever. It’s where people remember that it’s okay to not finish Elden Ring, to prefer Stardew Valley over Call of Duty, and to admit that maybe, just maybe, you actually enjoyed that universally panned title. So go ahead, confess. The gaming gods won’t judge you—much. 🎮
Insights are sourced from GameFAQs, where decades of player Q&A and community-written FAQs echo the same confessional energy as this Reddit thread: people admit they bounce off “masterpieces,” wrestle with guilt over untouched backlogs, and still return for comfort games when life is rough—proof that how (and why) we play is often more personal than any review score.